Sunday, October 18, 2026
Child Education. Montessori. Positivism. Moral Skepticism
Ninth chapter in the series. Previously: I have implemented the Maricarmen Longevity Decree at home, This is my vote in the elections thinking about longevity, A guide for my daughter on housing, victimhood, effort, and longevity, , , , and .
Throughout this series, I have told you that I am a moral skeptic. That perhaps a higher good exists, but that if it does, it is out of our reach. That in practice, the good and evil we deal with are opinions of individuals and groups.
And then I get home, my daughter does something I consider wrong, and I tell her: "You don't do that."
I don't tell her "it depends." I don't tell her "it's a cultural convention." I don't explain to her that Protagoras thought man is the measure of all things. I tell her you don't do that. Period.
Am I a hypocrite?
I don't think so. It is exactly what needs to be done. And, curiously, it is what the very ethics I believe in says.
The paradox
The paradox is this: I live in the nuance, but a little girl cannot be given nuance. She must be given solid ground.
It is not just my opinion. The psychologist Jean Piaget observed that young children view rules as something sacred and untouchable: the rules exist just because, and whoever breaks them is bad. Later, Lawrence Kohlberg described moral development like a ladder. On the first rungs, good is what you are rewarded for and bad is what you are punished for. Then comes what your group approves of. And only at the end—and not everyone gets there—does the ability to ask oneself if the rules themselves are fair appear.
Giving moral skepticism to a four-year-old girl doesn't make her free. It leaves her without a compass. It is like teaching someone to question a map before they know how to read it.
It took me thirty years to arrive at my skepticism. And I arrived there from a base. Children need their own, too.
Why it is not hypocrisy
In the [missing link] I told you that, in practice, I identify with virtue ethics. I don't ask myself so much what rule to follow, but rather what kind of person I want to be.
And Aristotle, the father of that ethics, was very clear in the Nicomachean Ethics about how virtue is learned: not with sermons, but with habit. No one becomes brave by reading about bravery. One becomes brave by doing brave things, again and again, until they come naturally. First, you practice. Understanding comes later.
So when I tell my daughter "you don't do that," I am not betraying my skepticism. I am applying my ethics. I am helping her build the habit. The time will come for her to understand why. And, much later, the time to question it.
Montessori: what fits and what I watch
At home, we operate within the Montessori philosophy, which fits very well with virtue ethics:
- You learn by doing. With your hands, repeating, practicing. Just like virtue.
- The goal is flourishing. Maria Montessori talked about helping the child develop their full potential. Aristotle called it eudaimonia, the full life. It is the same idea with two thousand years of difference.
- "Help me do it myself." The goal is autonomy. That good behavior comes from within, not from an adult watching.
But there are three things I watch out for, because I think they are the weak points of how it is usually applied:
- Excessive optimism. Montessori trusted a lot that the child, in the right environment, tends naturally toward good and order. I, who talk so much about genes, am not so sure. Our nature also brings selfishness, jealousy, and aggression. Virtue does not always sprout on its own. Sometimes you have to cultivate it against the current.
- Limits. Montessori defended freedom within limits. But many people keep the freedom and forget the limits. Learning to accept a "no" and to tolerate frustration is also part of character.
- Individualism. So much focus on one's own rhythm can make one forget that virtue is also learned in community, by imitating people you admire.
Positive psychology: the same family
The other leg is positive psychology. And here the connection is even more direct.
In the early 2000s, psychologists Martin Seligman and Christopher Peterson, fathers of positive psychology, reviewed the great philosophical and religious traditions of the world looking for which virtues were repeated in all of them. They found six: wisdom, courage, humanity, justice, temperance, and transcendence. And they broke them down into 24 character strengths, such as curiosity, honesty, perseverance, or gratitude.
If you are curious, there is a free test to learn your strengths on the VIA Institute on Character website.
It is, literally, virtue ethics in a lab coat. And their model of well-being, which they call PERMA (positive emotions, engagement, relationships, meaning, and achievement), is a modern version of Aristotle's full life.
My only caution is the usual one: positive psychology sometimes slides into easy positive thinking, that of "be happy and that's it." And it forgets that there is suffering that educates. As I told you in chapter 6, not all suffering is empty. A well-accompanied frustration is one of the best schools that exists.
What virtues I want them to have
If I had to choose, these are the virtues I would like my daughters to have at eighteen:
- That they take care of themselves. Of their health, their body, and their head.
- That they be committed. To their family, to their word, and to what they start.
- That they be honest. Above all with those they love most.
- That they be compassionate. That they care about the suffering of others.
- That they be curious. That they don't stop asking questions.
- That they have order. Not rigidity, but structure and the ability to plan.
- That they accept their humanity. With its limits and its emotions.
- That they know how to fend for themselves. That they don't depend on anyone for the essential.
- That they think as strategists. That they don't just put in effort, but choose well where they put that effort.
None of these virtues are taught with a speech. They are taught with small daily practices, repeated a thousand times. Self-care, with routines of sleep, food, and movement that are non-negotiable. Commitment, finishing what one starts, even if it is a puzzle. Order, returning each thing to its place, which is one of the foundations of Montessori. Curiosity, answering their questions with another question: "And what do you think?" Compassion, putting a name to what the other person feels: "Look, he is sad because you took his toy."
It is what Aristotle said: we are what we repeatedly do.
If you look at the list, obedience does not appear. Nor submission. Nor sacrifice for the sake of sacrifice.
And the truth is, between an obedient daughter and a daughter who questions, I am clear that I prefer the one who questions. Although I know what that means: that one day she will question me. My schedules, my quirks, and my inconsistencies. If I really want that, I will have to endure it even when it makes me uncomfortable. And not just when it is funny.
That said, there are things that are non-negotiable, out of pure survival. "If I tell you to stop, you stop." With a car coming, there is no time for debate. So it is not obedience or questioning. It is obedience in the essential and increasing questioning in everything else. The art lies in moving things from one bag to the other as they grow.
How I do it day-to-day
Connect before explaining. When a small child has a tantrum, the rational part of her brain is, literally, disconnected. Emotion rules. The psychiatrist Daniel Siegel explains it in The Whole-Brain Child with a rule that I think is golden: connect and then redirect. First calm and connection. And only when they are available again, the explanation. Explaining something to them in the middle of a tantrum is like talking to a closed door.
I confess one thing: what comes out of me in those moments is not anger. Sometimes it is to flee. And others, to go straight to explaining and negotiating. What I would like to come out is calm and connection first. I am working on it.
Neither punish nor reward: guide. Montessori rejected both things, because both are control from the outside. The child ends up behaving well to avoid punishment or get the reward, not because they have understood anything. Reward and punishment create a puppet. Guidance creates a compass.
Now then, I am not dogmatic. Sometimes a sticker or a consequence helps to jumpstart a habit when they still don't have the maturity for self-discipline. I use them as scaffolding. The scaffolding is not the house, but sometimes without it, the wall doesn't go up. The key is to not forget to take it down.
Imagination yes, lying no. When my daughter tells something that is not true, many times I play along. At those ages, fantasy and reality are mixed, and an invented story is not a lie: it is imagination. When it is something more serious, I make her see it and I explain why lying is wrong.
Two ideas have helped me here. The first, separating the two worlds with a simple question: "Is this for real or for pretend?" That way we play at imagining, but she learns there is a boundary. The second, that telling the truth pays off. Researchers Victoria Talwar and Kang Lee compared children from a school with severe punishments with children from another without them, and they found that the former lied more and better. If I want my daughters to tell me the truth when they have messed up, telling me cannot be what they fear most. "Thanks for telling me. Now let's fix it."
Honesty with those close to you
There is an idea that I have had a hard time formulating and that I think I want to pass on to them. With people you don't know, kindness comes first and honesty is dosed. With the people you love most, total honesty. Even if you have to be cold. Even if it hurts.
Almost all of us function backwards: we are charming outside our doors and we take our bad mood out at home. I think honesty is not something you spend with those you trust. It is what you owe them.
It is similar to another principle that I usually follow. Maximum self-demand with oneself. Maximum empathy with others.
But with nuances. Total honesty is not saying everything, all the time, without a filter. One can be completely honest and choose the moment and the words. Otherwise, "I'm just very sincere" ends up being the excuse of those who do harm for free.
And, again, order matters. A small girl doesn't know who is close and who is far. If I teach her from the start that with some yes and with others no, what she will understand is that lying is sometimes okay. First, the firm rule: the truth is told. The nuance, when she is older.
Radical self-sufficiency
There is a principle of Burning Man that marked me when I was there, and that I wrote about then: radical self-reliance, radical self-sufficiency. In the desert, everyone brings their own water. No one is going to give it to you. I reminded you of it in the [missing link] as one of my principles for adult life.
The funny thing is that Montessori is exactly that, but in child size. "Help me do it myself." Getting dressed by herself, pouring her own water, setting the table, cleaning up, preparing her own snack. Every time I do something for my daughter that she can already do, I am taking away an opportunity for her to be self-sufficient. And it is hard for me, because it is almost always faster to do it myself.
Over the years, self-sufficiency changes shape. First it is tying shoes. Later, managing her own money, with an allowance and her own decisions about what to spend it on. Later, knowing how to earn it, save it, and protect it. And, in the end, being able to choose her life without depending on anyone to solve it for her.
But I want to be clear about something: self-sufficiency is not individualism or loneliness. At Burning Man, self-sufficiency coexists with another principle, that of community. Being self-sufficient is being able to sustain yourself, not having to do everything alone. Knowing how to ask for help and having a network of trusted people is also being self-sufficient. That is why commitment to others is on the same list.
Be a strategist, not just a worker
If I had to choose one single thing that I would have liked to learn sooner, it would be this: effort is not enough. There is a correlation between effort and result, but it depends very much on where you put that effort. Rowing hard in the wrong direction only takes you away faster.
Being a strategist is thinking before rowing. And it has three parts that I want my daughters to learn:
- Knowing what you want. What lifestyle do I desire? Where do I want to live it? Almost no one asks themselves this seriously.
- Looking at the scenario with honesty. Is it possible to achieve it in current circumstances? And if it is not, what is easier, changing the circumstances or changing myself?
- Anticipating. Imagining several scenarios, not just the one I would like, and having a plan for each one.
This last one has an effect that is not usually mentioned: it protects against frustration. Much frustration is born from expectations not corresponding to reality. Whoever has anticipated several scenarios and prepared for them is less surprised, and suffers less when things don't turn out as they expected.
And there is a phrase that summarizes the underlying attitude and that I want them to have engraved: "It is not your fault, but it is your responsibility." Many things that happen to us we don't choose. But what we do with them, we do.
How do you teach a little girl to be a strategist? With questions. "What would happen if...?" "And if it rains, what do we do?" "You have this allowance: do you spend it now or wait until you save up for what you really want?" With board games, which are pure strategy. And planning the day or a trip together, so she sees that things don't happen on their own: they are prepared.
The NGO syndrome
There is a risk that worries me especially, and precisely because I want my daughters to be compassionate. I call it the NGO syndrome, and I already told you about it in the guide for my daughter.
It is a pattern that I see a lot in brilliant, generous, and hardworking people. They choose the most emotional and direct path to do good, they give themselves one hundred percent and reach forty having given a lot to others, but without a cushion, without assets and, many times, burned out. And the cause loses someone who wanted to keep helping.
They didn't lack effort. They lacked strategy.
I am not saying that helping others is wrong. On the contrary. I am talking about doing it without ever having done the math. Effective altruism, which I told you about in this article, proposes questions that almost no one asks: if I don't take this position, would someone else just as good take it? Would I do more good by earning more and funding three positions instead of occupying one? Can I sustain this for forty years without breaking?
Sometimes the answer is the NGO. But it should be an answer, not a starting point.
That is why compassion and strategy go together on my list. Compassion without strategy burns out. Strategy without compassion becomes cold. Together, they do a lot of good for a long time.
In stages
If I had to summarize how I plan to do it, it would be something like this:
- From 0 to 6 years old: clear norms and habits. Few norms, firm and taught above all by example. "No hitting." "Tell the truth." "Take care of what belongs to everyone." And lots of practical autonomy: let her do everything she can already do by herself. Without philosophy. They need a map, not a debate about whether the map exists.
- From 7 to 12 years old: the reasons. Now yes, the why. "We don't hit because it hurts the other person just like it hurts you." Here enters empathy, putting yourself in the other's place. And the first exceptions: why sometimes it is not necessary to say everything you think. It is also the stage of the first allowance, of the first decisions with consequences and of the first "what if...?" The seed of the strategist.
- Adolescence: the nuance. That cultures disagree. That it is difficult to know what is good. That one must doubt even oneself. And also about dad. At that age, skepticism no longer disarms them. It makes them critical and difficult to manipulate. And it is the time for big strategy conversations: what to study, where to live, how to earn a living and how to help others without falling into the NGO syndrome.
What I don't plan to do is ever hide from them that I doubt. When they are ready, I will tell them all this. I will tell them that I taught them that the good existed because they needed it, and that I wasn't sure. And that the decision about what to believe now is theirs.
First roots, then wings
There is an image that summarizes all this. You have to give a child roots first and then wings.
The roots are the norms, the habits, and the virtues. The ability to fend for themselves and to think before rowing. What holds them when the wind blows. The wings are the ability to question everything, including what you taught them.
Moral skepticism is wings. And they seem like magnificent wings to me. But without roots, the first wind takes whoever has them away.
So yes: I teach them that the good exists, even if I am not sure. Not out of hypocrisy. Because it is the only way that one day they can decide for themselves if it exists.
And if in fifteen years one of them takes apart all these arguments of mine, I will know I did it well.
A hug,
Gonzalo
-